Masonry vs Prefab Fireplace: Which Belongs in a Florida Home?
A masonry fireplace is built on site from block, firebrick and real brick or natural stone. It stands on its own footing and vents through a masonry chimney. A prefab fireplace is a factory-built unit, tested and listed as one product. It is framed into a wall and vents through a factory-built chimney.
Prefab fits when cost comes first, since its ranges in the cost guides top out lower. Masonry fits a new custom home or an addition, where the footing and chimney go on the plans early. In Florida, an indoor wood-burning fireplace is the less common request. When you do want one, we build custom masonry indoor fireplaces alongside your builder.
How do masonry and prefab fireplaces compare?
The code sections below come from the Florida Building Code, Residential.
| Masonry fireplace | Prefab (factory-built) fireplace | |
|---|---|---|
| How it is made | Built on site: a block core, a firebrick firebox and a brick or natural stone face | Made in a factory as one unit, then framed into a wall |
| Code path | Section R1001, the masonry fireplace rules | Listed and labeled, tested to UL 127, installed per its listing (R1004.1) |
| Weight and footing | Heavy; a concrete or solid masonry footing at least 12 inches thick | Set in place as its listing says; the footing rule is written for masonry fireplaces |
| Clearance to framing | At least 2 inches at the front and sides, 4 inches at the back (R1001.11) | Set by the unit’s listing |
| Chimney | A lined masonry chimney, at least 3 feet above the roof where it passes through | A listed factory-built chimney, installed and capped as the maker’s instructions say (R1005.1) |
| Firebox | A firebrick lining at least 2 inches thick, at least 20 inches deep | Built into the factory unit and tested with it |
| Hearth | At least 4 inches thick; the extension reaches 16 inches out and 8 inches to each side | Installed per the listing, and easy to tell apart from the floor (R1004.2) |
| Finish | Real clay brick or natural stone, brick arches, a herringbone firebrick back | A face around the unit, as its listing allows |
| Upkeep | Block and brick do not rust or rot; firebrick is made for the heat | Follow the maker’s instructions for the unit and its chimney |
| Market cost | $3,500 to $5,600 in one guide; $10,000 or more for a mason-built brick fireplace | $2,000 to $3,000 for a prefab brick fireplace; $3,000 to $8,000 for a prefab wood-burning unit |
How is a masonry fireplace built?
A masonry fireplace goes up one course at a time. Ours start with a concrete block core. The firebox gets a firebrick lining, since firebrick is made for the heat. The face is real clay brick or natural stone.
Section R1001 of the code sets the masonry rules. The firebox must be at least 20 inches deep, with firebrick at least 2 inches thick. The hearth is at least 4 inches thick. Its extension reaches 16 inches in front of the opening and 8 inches past each side. For openings of 6 square feet or more, those become 20 and 12 inches.
All that masonry is heavy. The code calls for a footing of concrete or solid masonry at least 12 inches thick. It must reach 6 inches past the fireplace on all sides. A national cost guide notes that a masonry build may mean pouring a new foundation for the added weight.
The chimney is masonry too, and masonry chimneys must be lined. It stands at least 3 feet above where it passes through the roof. It also rises 2 feet higher than any part of the building within 10 feet. Wood framing keeps 2 inches from the fireplace’s front and sides and 4 inches from its back. Inside the house, framing keeps 2 inches from a masonry chimney, too.
How is a prefab fireplace built?
A prefab fireplace arrives as a complete unit, firebox included. Section R1004 says it must be listed and labeled and installed as its listing says. It must be tested to UL 127, the standard the code names for factory-built fireplaces. Some are sold as zero-clearance fireplaces.
The listing sets how close the framing can come. The hearth extension goes in per the listing, too. It must be easy to tell apart from the floor around it.
The chimney is factory-built as well. It must be listed and labeled, then installed and capped as the maker’s instructions say. For a wood-burning unit in a home, that chimney must meet UL 103. A decorative shroud on top is allowed only when it is listed for that exact fireplace system.
What does each one cost?
National cost guides give these ranges. They are market numbers, not our price list.
- One guide: a new masonry fireplace, $3,500 to $5,600
- The same guide: an authentic mason-built brick fireplace, $10,000 or more
- The same guide: a prefabricated brick fireplace, $2,000 to $3,000
- The same guide: a prefabricated wood-burning unit, $3,000 to $8,000 to install
- A second guide: wood-burning fireplaces of all kinds, $2,500 to $30,000 to install
- The second guide: a new chimney, which can add $4,000 to $8,000 on average
The ranges overlap, and the low masonry figure sits inside the prefab range. Read it with care. The same guide says a mason-built brick fireplace can cost $10,000 or more, above both of its prefab ranges. When you compare prices, check whether each one covers the footing and the chimney.
Which one fits a Florida home?
A masonry fireplace makes sense when:
- you are building a new custom home or an addition, with the footing and chimney on the plans
- you want real clay brick or natural stone, with brick arches cut on site over the opening
- you want a wood fire in a firebrick firebox sized to the room
A prefab unit makes sense when:
- cost comes first, since prefab ranges in the guides top out lower
- the room has no place for a masonry footing and chimney
Gas and electric units are another product line. A licensed gas contractor or a retailer handles those, along with inserts and gas logs. For a fire on the patio instead, see our outdoor fireplace kit vs masonry guide.
Who builds what on an indoor masonry fireplace?
An indoor fireplace is part of the house. We build the fireplace; your builder handles the permit and the structure. That includes the framing around it and the roof the chimney passes through.
The code also calls for an outside air supply to the fireplace. The exception is a room whose mechanical ventilation keeps indoor pressure neutral or positive. Put it on the plans with your builder early.
We do not sell or install factory-built units, inserts or gas logs. Our masons build the masonry kind: the firebox, the hearth, the chimney and the brick or stone face.
Where should you start?
If a masonry fireplace fits your plans, see how we build masonry fireplaces inside the home. We look at the plans and the space and give you a quote. Call (407) 702-4316, and we will get back to you.